The "received wisdom" in Disney fan circles is that MyMagic+ (NextGen) is a boondoggle; a waste of more than one billion dollars. No way is Disney going to recoup that investment, they say, and it's so lamentable because that kind of coin could have bought a huge number of new rides, maybe even its own theme park! Instead we get wristband replacements for admission tickets, privacy incursions, and ride reservations that some people don't even want.
Well, the received wisdom might be a bit premature. If you look steadily, evenly, and calmly at the numbers, I think you'll find that Disney probably know what it's doing. I think they WILL see a return on investment. The main reasons that the community has not come to the same conclusion are the dual problems of scale and timeframe.
Let's start with timeframe. Disney isn't going to expect a $1 billion boost in the first year. Let's pretend they expected the gains to be spread out over many years--say, 20 years--the way one amortizes the depreciation of capital investments. That's 50 million dollars a year (assuming for a moment there is no such thing as inflation, future value of money, or opportunity cost from NOT investing money that would otherwise have been in pocket).
Let's be generous. Let's say Disney wanted to recoup its investment in ten years, rather than twenty. That's $100 million each year additional profit that needs to be earned to justify this expensive endeavor. Impossible, right?
Not impossible when you bring the scale into this equation. Each year, 30 million people visit Walt Disney World. Let me say that again: 30 million. If each of them spends an additional $4 dollars OVER THE COURSE OF THEIR ENTIRE TRIP then you've already made up those $100 million needed to justify NextGen. Well, let's call it $5 or even $6 to account for the difference between revenue and profit. Heck, let's call it $10 per person just to err on the side of caution.
Are you telling me that a family of four visiting from Wyoming for a week in 2017, having made ride reservations and lunch reservations, won't use some of that downtime to go shopping? They have seven days of shopping (since their vacation lasts seven days) and they only need to spend an additional $40 that they wouldn't have otherwise to make up the difference. If they were visiting for one day I could see them resisting those "additional purchases." Maybe even two or three days. But seven days of luxury in the parks, with no real need to wait in lines? I think they will eventually nibble.
All of the above assumes that people don't make additional purchases because Disney targeted them (they know now, courtesy of those wristbands, which rides are your favorites). Or that people won't go to Disney instead of Universal because the ride reservations will be seen as beneficial and convenient (hey, it WILL be true for some people).
In many ways, Disney is not in the theme park business anymore, but in the hotel business. If the perk is good enough, Disney can get more people to stay at its hotels. The perk appears to be an extra number of advanced reservations. From Disney's point of view, this is win-win. The reservations cost almost nothing from an operational point of view (once NextGen is paid for), but they could bring hotel bookings up to 100%. Forget $10/trip. We could be talking a lot more than that, in terms of additional money rolling in.
And then there's the trump card: saving face. Even if we assume the worst-case scenario, that Disney actually never makes additional money from these investments, I think we can say that Disney will never admit the failure. They will simply invest more in the parks and "roll together" the expense of NextGen with other capitol improvements. Carsland, Avatar, Disney Springs... they will all drive attendance. Personally, I think we are less than two years out from Disney announcing a major, major Star Wars land (or even park). That will be rolled in also.
Make no mistake. Disney will spin NextGen as a success, whether it really *is* (I think it will be) or whether it has to be combined with other capitol improvements.
Edit: an early tweeted reply to this post reminded me that there are also operational savings to be had by this technology. One of the early goals of the original FastPass was to "spread out" demand for the ride. With advance reservations, people really will be arriving earlier in the day to get on their coasters, and the ride will be better "optimized." Disney can also close rides earlier and save money - the $4/person can be had merely in savings, in some cases. Extra Magic Hour is likely to become a thing of the past, since Disney has a new "thing" to promote as the reason for staying at their hotels (you get more reservations).
---
Kevin Yee is the author of numerous independent Disney books, including the popular Walt Disney World Earbook series and Walt Disney World Hidden History.
Showing posts with label Avatar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Avatar. Show all posts
Thursday, March 14, 2013
Sunday, July 15, 2012
New location for Festival of the Lion King at DAK?
Disney is moving the meet and greet "character trails" from Camp Minnie-Mickey over to Discovery Island, to the Beastly Bazaar shop. This was announced to Cast Members back in June, so that much is certain. But this bit of news has led to much well-founded speculation. Why move the characters? The obvious implication is that they need the land for something else--Avatar, which is slated to start construction in 2013 and be done in 2016, when the next cycle of movies for the Avatar universe will be arriving in theaters (presumably with much hype).
That matches the chatter. Insiders whispered that the two plots of land considered for Avatar were behind Everest (an area once considered for Australia) and this land on Camp Minnie-Mickey. The current land was once slated for Beastlie Kingdomme, which is why the park's logo has a dragon on it and there's a stone dragon along the river, and the footprint for Beastlie Kingdomme was even bigger than Camp Minnie-Mickey. There's more space to the outsides, especially pushing out "into" the parking lot. That bump also looks enticingly like maybe an operational advantage. Could they keep this section of the park open later than everything else, and just funnel people out to the parking lot directly?
But for all of that to happen, they will need to remove the Festival of the Lion King arena. Will they just end the show? That seems unlikely. This show has the highest Guest satisfaction of ANY show in Walt Disney World; people just like the songs and react well to the themes. I agree. It's a great show.
So if not removing the attraction, one assumes they will MOVE it. But move it where? Some online musings suspected an area behind Tusker House, presently backstage. I'm not sure that's large enough.
I think they will build a new theater in the space "between" Africa and Asia, and call it part of Africa (where the Lion King is set). That makes more sense for a location for this theater anyway--why was it part of the Adirondacks-themed Camp Minnie-Mickey? (Answer: convenience).
If you're familiar with this path, it's "behind" the Tamu Tamu quick service window. There's a side path here that leads to a hut sometimes used for character interaction, but it's not a well-traveled path. And for those of you who know the park really well, you will remember there was a side path off the side path - a completely unpaved trail through the forest. It was a real break from the usual Disney experience; it was "wild" and that was the point. You even walked across a stream or two. Several years back, that unpaved trail was deemed operationally to be undesirable, so they used plants to close off the entrance to the trail (it's now hard to find). You can still see the pavers across the stream, though.
This is the area that is likely to be the home to the new Lion King show. It's a good location, and will draw traffic to this corner of the park. All good news!
---
Kevin Yee is the author of numerous independent Disney books, including the popular Walt Disney World Earbook series and Walt Disney World Hidden History.
That matches the chatter. Insiders whispered that the two plots of land considered for Avatar were behind Everest (an area once considered for Australia) and this land on Camp Minnie-Mickey. The current land was once slated for Beastlie Kingdomme, which is why the park's logo has a dragon on it and there's a stone dragon along the river, and the footprint for Beastlie Kingdomme was even bigger than Camp Minnie-Mickey. There's more space to the outsides, especially pushing out "into" the parking lot. That bump also looks enticingly like maybe an operational advantage. Could they keep this section of the park open later than everything else, and just funnel people out to the parking lot directly?
But for all of that to happen, they will need to remove the Festival of the Lion King arena. Will they just end the show? That seems unlikely. This show has the highest Guest satisfaction of ANY show in Walt Disney World; people just like the songs and react well to the themes. I agree. It's a great show.
So if not removing the attraction, one assumes they will MOVE it. But move it where? Some online musings suspected an area behind Tusker House, presently backstage. I'm not sure that's large enough.
I think they will build a new theater in the space "between" Africa and Asia, and call it part of Africa (where the Lion King is set). That makes more sense for a location for this theater anyway--why was it part of the Adirondacks-themed Camp Minnie-Mickey? (Answer: convenience).
If you're familiar with this path, it's "behind" the Tamu Tamu quick service window. There's a side path here that leads to a hut sometimes used for character interaction, but it's not a well-traveled path. And for those of you who know the park really well, you will remember there was a side path off the side path - a completely unpaved trail through the forest. It was a real break from the usual Disney experience; it was "wild" and that was the point. You even walked across a stream or two. Several years back, that unpaved trail was deemed operationally to be undesirable, so they used plants to close off the entrance to the trail (it's now hard to find). You can still see the pavers across the stream, though.
This is the area that is likely to be the home to the new Lion King show. It's a good location, and will draw traffic to this corner of the park. All good news!
---
Kevin Yee is the author of numerous independent Disney books, including the popular Walt Disney World Earbook series and Walt Disney World Hidden History.
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
Avatar Construction - Step One About to Start
The Cast Member online "portal" (employee-only Web site) reported this week that the shop Beastly Bazaar will be converted to an air-conditioned character greeting location. Beastly Bazaar will close on August 12.
On the surface of things, this is quite positive. Disney's Animal Kingdom (DAK) has always suffered from its reputation as a "hot" park, since so few attractions and experiences make use of air conditioning. In that sense, this move seems fan-friendly.
There have been other changes to characters lately in DAK. Goofy can only be seen in Dinoland, and his former home in Camp Minnie-Mickey is presently used for King Louie and Baloo. Some of the other DAK-specific characters (Thumper, Timon, Daisy, Meeko) are no longer appearing.
Insiders whisper that the Beastly Bazaar location will be used for the Camp Minnie-Mickey characters, meaning that land will be left vacant.
What's behind all this? Avatar. This mega-expansion of DAK will add a new land, rumored to cost up to $500 million, and is slated to open by 2016, when the first of the Avatar sequels (there may be up to three sequels in total) will be in theaters. The timing was carefully chosen to open the land when the Avatar hype will likely be at a fever pitch, and will hopefully intensify as further Avatar sequels are released.
Disney hasn't admitted publicly that Avatar is behind the move, but there seems little doubt. Disney would not spend the money to refurbish a perfectly good (not to mention profit-generating) store unless they had some other plan for the land where the characters are now, in Camp Minnie-Mickey.
Festival of the Lion King would have to move if Avatar comes here; it's likely to end up in Africa.
For a new land on the scale of Avatar to open by 2016, construction and land clearing will have to start by 2013, maybe a touch into 2012. Disney has not said publicly where the land will be located, but several insiders report that after flirting with an expansion plot behind Kali River Rapids, planners have settled on the Camp Minnie-Mickey plot, as well as some additional land just outside Camp Minnie-Mickey that was held in reserve for the original idea for this corner of the park, Beastlie Kingdomme (Camp Minnie-Mickey was always meant to be temporary).
The additional land (marked in red in the map above, versus yellow for Camp Minnie-Mickey) has the added bonus that it sits up against the parking lot. If the attractions are laid out just right, perhaps they can allow visitors to stay late in this land alone while the rest of the park closes, and then be funneled out directly to the parking lot. DAK can finally be a late-night park instead of just a half-day park.
Thus, this move of the characters out of the hot August air is not really about air conditioning and Guest service. It's about tall blue aliens with horse tails. It's the first of what is sure to be many reports of construction and groundwork being done for the Avatar expansion, rumored to be the last big expansion in Walt Disney World (and all stateside parks) for quite a while.
And so it begins!
---
Kevin Yee is the author of numerous independent Disney books, including the popular Walt Disney World Earbook series and Walt Disney World Hidden History.
There have been other changes to characters lately in DAK. Goofy can only be seen in Dinoland, and his former home in Camp Minnie-Mickey is presently used for King Louie and Baloo. Some of the other DAK-specific characters (Thumper, Timon, Daisy, Meeko) are no longer appearing.
Insiders whisper that the Beastly Bazaar location will be used for the Camp Minnie-Mickey characters, meaning that land will be left vacant.
What's behind all this? Avatar. This mega-expansion of DAK will add a new land, rumored to cost up to $500 million, and is slated to open by 2016, when the first of the Avatar sequels (there may be up to three sequels in total) will be in theaters. The timing was carefully chosen to open the land when the Avatar hype will likely be at a fever pitch, and will hopefully intensify as further Avatar sequels are released.
Disney hasn't admitted publicly that Avatar is behind the move, but there seems little doubt. Disney would not spend the money to refurbish a perfectly good (not to mention profit-generating) store unless they had some other plan for the land where the characters are now, in Camp Minnie-Mickey.
Festival of the Lion King would have to move if Avatar comes here; it's likely to end up in Africa.
For a new land on the scale of Avatar to open by 2016, construction and land clearing will have to start by 2013, maybe a touch into 2012. Disney has not said publicly where the land will be located, but several insiders report that after flirting with an expansion plot behind Kali River Rapids, planners have settled on the Camp Minnie-Mickey plot, as well as some additional land just outside Camp Minnie-Mickey that was held in reserve for the original idea for this corner of the park, Beastlie Kingdomme (Camp Minnie-Mickey was always meant to be temporary).
The additional land (marked in red in the map above, versus yellow for Camp Minnie-Mickey) has the added bonus that it sits up against the parking lot. If the attractions are laid out just right, perhaps they can allow visitors to stay late in this land alone while the rest of the park closes, and then be funneled out directly to the parking lot. DAK can finally be a late-night park instead of just a half-day park.
Thus, this move of the characters out of the hot August air is not really about air conditioning and Guest service. It's about tall blue aliens with horse tails. It's the first of what is sure to be many reports of construction and groundwork being done for the Avatar expansion, rumored to be the last big expansion in Walt Disney World (and all stateside parks) for quite a while.
And so it begins!
---
Kevin Yee is the author of numerous independent Disney books, including the popular Walt Disney World Earbook series and Walt Disney World Hidden History.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













